Aims and Scope Submissions Author Guidelines Copyright Notice & Licensing Publication Ethics Generative AI Policy Data Availability Ethical Statement Complaints and Appeals Peer Review Process Tools Editorial Team Reviewers Indexing Statistics Article Processing Charge Partnerships
Peer Review Process
Jurnal LITIGASI uses double-blind peer review: reviewers do not know the identity of the authors, and authors do not know the identity of the reviewers. All manuscripts are handled through the journal's online system. The process follows the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
Stages
- Initial screening (target: 14 days): An editor checks that the manuscript fits the Aims and Scope, follows the Author Guidelines and the current template, and is properly anonymized. The manuscript is also checked with Turnitin. Manuscripts outside the scope are declined; manuscripts with similarity above 20% or with formatting problems are returned to the authors before review.
- Peer review (reviewers have 4 weeks): Manuscripts that pass screening are sent to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the subject.
- Editorial decision (target: within 60 days of submission): The handling editor considers the reviewers' reports and recommends a decision to the Editor-in-Chief, who makes the final decision: Accept, Revisions Required, Resubmit for Review, or Decline. When reviewers disagree, the editor may invite an additional reviewer.
- Revision: Authors revise the manuscript and upload it with a response table explaining how each comment was addressed. Revisions are due within one month; later revisions are treated as new submissions. The revised manuscript may be returned to the reviewers.
- Final checks and production: Accepted manuscripts are checked with Turnitin again, proofread by the journal's designated proofreader, laid out, and sent to the authors for final proofreading before publication.
Editorial Decisions
- Who decides: At initial screening, the Editor-in-Chief or a handling editor decides whether a manuscript is sent to review or declined without review. After review, the Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision. Editors who make decisions on manuscripts have no role in APC invoicing.
- Automated tools: Turnitin is used to check similarity at screening and before publication, and every report is assessed by an editor. Editors do not use generative AI to screen manuscripts or make decisions (see the Generative AI Policy).
- Articles without peer review: Letters to the Editor are not peer reviewed and are labeled as such. All research articles and conceptual analyses are peer reviewed. Submission does not guarantee acceptance.
Reviewers
- Reviewers are scholars holding a doctorate or equivalent expertise in the relevant field of law, with a publication record in reputable journals within the last three years.
- Reviewers come from institutions in Indonesia and abroad. No reviewer is assigned a manuscript from their own institution or from co-authors.
- Reviewers write their comments directly in the manuscript file using the comment feature of Microsoft Word, section by section, and upload the commented file to the journal system together with their recommendation and a short overall assessment.
- Reviewers may not use generative AI tools to evaluate manuscripts or write reports (see the Generative AI Policy).
Review Criteria
Reviewers assess:
- relevance to the journal's scope and significance for legal scholarship;
- originality and the clarity of the novelty claimed;
- clarity of the legal problem and research objectives;
- appropriateness and transparency of the research method;
- depth and coherence of the legal analysis and argument;
- whether the conclusions follow from the analysis;
- currency and adequacy of the references and legal sources;
- quality of the writing and structure.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts and reviewer reports are confidential. Reviewers' names are not disclosed to authors. The list of reviewers who have contributed to the journal is published on the Reviewers page without linking them to specific articles.
Reviewer Selection
- Assignment: Reviewers are selected and invited by the handling editor. Automated or AI-based reviewer suggestions are not used.
- Suggested reviewers: Authors may suggest reviewers or ask that specific people be excluded. Suggestions are considered but not binding, and suggested reviewers are checked for conflicts of interest.
- Help from others: Reviewers may not share a manuscript with anyone or involve others, including students, in the review without the editor's prior permission.
- Contact with authors: Reviewers do not contact authors directly.
- Supplementary material: Supplementary files, such as interview guides or datasets, are sent to reviewers with the manuscript and are reviewed with it.
- Publication of reviews: Reviewer reports are not published. Authors receive the reports without the reviewers' names.
Delays and Withdrawal
If a manuscript takes longer than the targets stated above, the editor informs the authors of the reason. Authors may withdraw a manuscript at any stage before acceptance by notifying the editor.
Guidance for Editors and Reviewers
New editors receive an orientation on the review process, reviewer selection, conflicts of interest, handling inappropriate reviewer comments, and communicating revision requests. Reviewers receive written guidance with each invitation. Authors and reviewers may contact the editors at litigasi@unpas.ac.id with any questions.
Reference Management
Authors should use a reference manager such as Mendeley or Zotero and follow APA Style 7th Edition.

























