Aims and Scope Submissions Author Guidelines Copyright Notice & Licensing Publication Ethics Generative AI Policy Data Availability Ethical Statement Complaints and Appeals Peer Review Process Tools Editorial Team Reviewers Indexing Statistics Article Processing Charge Partnerships
Publication Ethics
Jurnal LITIGASI is committed to the highest standards of publication ethics. This statement follows the Core Practices and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and applies to authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher, the Faculty of Law, Universitas Pasundan.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Jurnal LITIGASI welcomes submissions from authors of every country, institution, and career stage. The journal seeks diversity in its editorial board and reviewer pool across countries, institutions, gender, and fields of law, and it reviews the composition of both bodies every year. The journal aims to make its website and articles accessible to all readers.
Duties of Editors
- Publication decisions: The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for deciding which manuscripts are published, based on the reviewers' reports, the manuscript's originality, rigor, and relevance to the journal's scope. Decisions are never influenced by article processing charges, institutional affiliation, or the authors' personal characteristics.
- Fair play: Manuscripts are evaluated on their intellectual content without regard to the authors' race, gender, sexual orientation, religious belief, ethnic origin, citizenship, or political views.
- Confidentiality: Editors do not disclose information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, and other editorial advisers, as appropriate.
- Editorial independence: Editorial decisions are made on academic grounds only and are free from interference by the publisher, sponsors, or any other party.
Duties of Reviewers
- Contribution to decisions: Reviewers assist the editor in making decisions and help authors improve their manuscripts.
- Promptness: A reviewer who feels unqualified, or who cannot complete the review on time, notifies the editor promptly and declines the invitation.
- Confidentiality: Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. Reviewers may not share them or upload any part of them to generative AI tools (see the Generative AI Policy).
- Objectivity: Reviews are conducted objectively, with clear and supported arguments. Personal criticism of the authors is inappropriate.
- Acknowledgment of sources: Reviewers point out relevant work that has not been cited and alert the editor to any substantial overlap with other published work.
Duties of Authors
- Reporting standards: Authors present an accurate account of their work and an objective discussion of its significance. Fabricated or falsified data and knowingly inaccurate statements are unacceptable.
- Originality: Authors ensure that the work is entirely original and that the work and words of others are properly cited or quoted.
- Multiple or concurrent submission: A manuscript may not be under consideration by another journal at the same time, and the same research may not be published in more than one primary publication.
- Fundamental errors: Authors who discover a significant error in their published work notify the editor promptly and cooperate in correcting or retracting the article.
Authorship and Contributorship
Authorship is limited to those who have made a substantial contribution to the conception, design, research, analysis, or writing of the work, have approved the final version, and agree to be accountable for it. Everyone who meets these criteria must be listed as an author; others who contributed should be acknowledged.
- Authors are asked to describe each author's contribution using the CRediT taxonomy in the Declarations section of the manuscript.
- Changes to the author list (adding, removing, or reordering authors) after submission require a written request from the corresponding author, explaining the reason and signed by all authors. Authors may not be added after a manuscript has been accepted.
- Generative AI tools cannot be listed as authors.
- Authorship disputes: Disputes about authorship are handled following COPE guidance. The journal does not adjudicate disputes; it asks the authors to resolve them among themselves, and the manuscript does not proceed until all authors agree in writing. If the authors cannot agree, the journal refers the matter to their institutions. If a dispute arises after publication, a correction is published only after the disagreement has been resolved.
Conflicts of Interest
- Definition: A conflict of interest exists when a personal, financial, political, religious, academic, professional, or institutional interest could influence, or be seen to influence, the preparation, review, or publication of a manuscript.
- Authors: Authors declare all potential conflicts of interest in the Declarations section of the manuscript at submission. Authors with no conflicts state: "The authors declare no conflict of interest."
- Reviewers: Reviewers declare any conflict to the editor when invited and decline the review if the conflict is significant.
- Editors: Editors with a conflict of interest withdraw from handling the manuscript and from the decision. A manuscript submitted by a member of the editorial team is handled by another editor, is reviewed under the same double-blind process, and its author has no access to its review records. Editorial team members may publish no more than one article in the journal per year.
- Compensation: Editors and staff are not paid or rewarded according to the number of manuscripts accepted.
- Undeclared conflicts: If an undeclared conflict comes to light before publication, the editor reassesses the manuscript and may decline it. If it comes to light after publication, the journal publishes a correction or, where the conflict undermines the article, follows the procedure for handling allegations of misconduct.
- Funding: Authors disclose all sources of funding and support for the research, including grant numbers, in the Declarations section. Authors who received no funding state: "This research received no external funding."
Plagiarism
- Definitions: Plagiarism is the use of another person's ideas, words, data, or other work without proper attribution. Self-plagiarism includes redundant (duplicate) publication, that is, publishing substantially the same work in more than one journal, and text recycling, that is, reusing substantial parts of one's own published text without citation. A translation of an article already published in another language is treated as duplicate publication unless the journal agrees in advance and the original is clearly cited.
- Preprints and theses: The journal considers manuscripts that have been posted as preprints or that are derived from a thesis or dissertation. Authors disclose this at submission. To protect double-blind review, authors do not replace the preprint with the reviewed version until the article is published.
All manuscripts are checked with Turnitin twice: at initial screening and again before publication.
- A manuscript with an overall similarity above 20%, or with a substantial block of text matching a single source, is returned to the authors before review.
- Similarity reports are assessed by an editor, not by percentage alone. Properly quoted and cited material, standard legal wording, and references are taken into account.
- Plagiarism found before publication leads to rejection. Plagiarism found after publication is handled under the procedures below and may lead to retraction.
Special Issues and Guest Editors
Special issues and themed sections within regular issues follow the same editorial and peer review standards as regular issues. Guest editors are appointed by the Editor-in-Chief on the basis of their expertise and publication record. Guest editors handle manuscripts and recommend decisions; the final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief. A manuscript submitted by a guest editor to their own special issue is handled by another editor. The journal does not publish conference proceedings.
Handling Allegations of Misconduct
Allegations of misconduct (such as plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, improper authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or duplicate publication) may be raised by anyone by email to litigasi@unpas.ac.id. The journal handles them following COPE flowcharts:
- Initial assessment: The Editor-in-Chief reviews the evidence within 14 days.
- Clarification: The authors are informed and asked to respond.
- Investigation: Where needed, the editor consults reviewers, editorial board members, or the authors' institution.
- Decision: The Editor-in-Chief decides on the outcome, documented in writing.
- Corrective action: Correction, expression of concern, retraction, or rejection, as described below. The complainant and authors are informed of the outcome.
Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions
- Correction (erratum or corrigendum) is published when an error does not undermine the main findings or conclusions.
- Expression of concern is published while an investigation is ongoing or when the evidence is inconclusive.
- Retraction is published when there is clear evidence of misconduct or a serious error that makes the findings or conclusions unreliable.
- Withdrawal applies only to manuscripts that have not yet been published.
The Editor-in-Chief decides on corrections and retractions after consultation with the editorial board. Every notice is published openly, states the reason and who issued it, and is linked to the original article. Retracted articles are not removed: they remain online, clearly watermarked "Retracted," and their DOI metadata is updated.
Post-Publication Discussion
Readers may comment on or correct published articles by writing to the Editor-in-Chief. Accepted contributions are published in the next issue as a Letter to the Editor, and the authors are given the opportunity to reply.
Copyright and Licensing
Authors who publish with Jurnal LITIGASI retain copyright of their work. Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0). The journal holds the right of first publication. See Copyright Notice & Licensing.
Related Policies
Peer Review Process · Generative AI Policy · Data Availability · Ethical Statement · Complaints and Appeals · Privacy Statement

























