Mapping The Contested Digital Space: A Bibliometric Analysis Of Religious Moderation And Extremism Counter-Narratives In Indonesian Millennial Studies

Authors

  • Rodliatul Millah Universitas Kiai Abdullah Faqih
  • M.Muizzudin Universitas Kiai Abdullah Faqih
  • Imam Nur Aziz Universitas Kiai Abdullah Faqih

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.23969/jp.v11i01.42236

Keywords:

Religious Moderation, Internalization of Values, Islamic Jurisprudence Learning

Abstract

This study provides a comprehensive bibliometric mapping of the contested digital landscape surrounding religious moderation and extremism counter-narratives, specifically focusing on Indonesian millennial studies. As digital platforms become the primary battlefield for ideological influencehis research evaluates how scholarly discourse has evolved to address the radicalization of the youth. Using a bibliometric approach, this study analyzed a significant corpus of high-quality documents indexed in the Scopus database from 2020 to 2025. Data visualization and thematic mapping were conducted to identify dominant subject areas, keyword co-occurrences, and the most influential research contributors. The results reveal a significant multidisciplinary shift; while traditionally a sociological concern, the field is now dominated by Computer Science (18.2%) and Engineering (16.4%), followed by Social Sciences (10.2%). This indicates that counter-extremism efforts are increasingly relying on algorithmic strategies and digital interventions. The thematic analysis highlights a "Digital-Wasathiyah" paradigm, where the integration of AI and data analytics is seen as vital for scaling moderate narratives. However, "blind spots" remain, particularly concerning the influence of Generative AI on religious authority and traditional learning models millennials. The study is limited to Scopus-indexed data. The findings imply that religious moderation in Indonesia is no longer just a theological challenge but a technological one, requiring a "human-centric" AI approach to preserve social cohesion.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Aly, A., Macdonald, S., Jarvis, L., & Chen, T. M. (2017). Violent Extremism Online: New Perspectives on Terrorism and the internet. Routledge.

Arifinsyah, Abdullah, M., x& Nurrahmah. (2020). Religious moderation in Indonesia. HTS Teologiese Studies, 76(1).

Biggs, J., x& Tang, C. (2011). Teaching xfor xQuality xLearning xat xUniversity. xHigher xEducation xResearch x& xDevelopment.

Borgatti, xS. xP., xAgneessens, xF., xJohnson, xJ. xC., x& xEverett, xM. xG. x(2022). xAnalyzing xsocial xnetworks xusing xR.

Börner, xK. x(2010). xAtlas xof xScience: xVisualizing xWhat xWe xKnow.

Campbell, xH. xA. x(2013). xDigital xReligion: xUnderstanding xReligious xPractice xin xNew xMedia xWorlds. xRoutledge.

Castells, xM. x(2010). xThe xPower xof xIdentity x(2nd xed.). xWiley-Blackwell.

Center, xP. xR. x(2019). xInternet, xSocial xMedia xUse, xand xTechnology xAdoption xamong xYoung xAdults.

Chen, xX., xLi, xJ., x& xLuo, xX. x(2022). xMachine xlearning xapproaches xto xonline xradicalization xand xcounter-extremism xresearch. xIEEE xAccess, x10, x112345–112358.

Cobo, xM. xJ., xLópez-Herrera, xA. xG., xHerrera-Viedma, xE., x& xHerrera, xF. x(2011). xScience xMapping xSoftware xTools: xReview, xAnalysis, xand xCooperative xStudy. xJournal xof xthe xAmerican xSociety xfor xInformation xScience xand xTechnology.

Conway, xM., xScrivens, xR., x& xMacnair, xL. x(2019). xDisrupting xextremist xcontent xonline. xStudies xin xConflict x& xTerrorism, x42(1–2), x1–24.

Crane, xD. x(1972). xInvisible xColleges: xDiffusion xof xKnowledge xin xScientific xCommunities. xUniversity xof xChicago xPress.

Cronbach, xL. xJ. x(1951). xCoefficient xAlpha xand xthe xInternal xStructure xof xTests. xPsychometrika.

DeVellis, xR. xF. x(2017). xScale xDevelopment: xTheory xand xApplications.

Donthu, xN., xKumar, xS., xMukherjee, xD., xPandey, xN., x& xLim, xW. xM. x(2021). xHow xto xConduct xa xBibliometric xAnalysis: xAn xOverview xand xGuidelines. xJournal xof xBusiness xResearch, x133, x285–296. xhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.04.070

Durlak, xJ. xA. x(2011). xThe xImpact xof xEnhancing xStudents’ xSocial xand xEmotional xLearning. xChild xDevelopment.

Elsevier. x(2024). xScopus xContent xCoverage xGuide. xElsevier xBV.

Facione, xP. xA. x(2013). xCritical xThinking: xWhat xIt xIs xand xWhy xIt xCounts. xEducational xResearch xReview.

Fajar, xA. xS. xM., xFauzi, xA., xDarmawan, xD., xPutra, xA. xR., x& xArifin, xS. x(2025). xTransformation xof xIslamic xReligious xEducation xin xthe xDigital xLandscape xand xits xImplications xfor xPedagogical xInnovation. xInternational xJournal xof xService xScience, xManagement, xEngineering, xand xTechnology, x8(1), x15–20.

Falagas, xM. xE., xPitsouni, xE. xI., xMalietzis, xG. xA., x& xPappas, xG. x(2008). xComparison xof xPubMed, xScopus, xWeb xof xScience, xand xGoogle xScholar. xFASEB xJournal, x22(2), x338–342.

Flavell, xJ. xH. x(1979). xMetacognition xand xCognitive xMonitoring: xA xNew xArea xof xCognitive–Developmental xInquiry. xAmerican xPsychologist.

Floridi, xL. x(2023). xThe xethics xof xartificial xintelligence: xPrinciples, xchallenges, xand xopportunities.

Freeman, xL. xC. x(1979). xCentrality xin xSocial xNetworks: xConceptual xClarification. xSocial xNetworks.

Heryanto, xA. x(2018). xIdentity xand xPleasure: xThe xPolitics xof xIndonesian xScreen xCulture. xNUS xPress.

Horgan, xJ. x(2005). xThe xPsychology xof xTerrorism. xPolitical xPsychology.

Kahne, xJ., x& xBowyer, xB. x(2017). xEducating xfor xDemocracy xin xa xPartisan xAge: xConfronting xthe xChallenges xof xMotivated xReasoning. xAmerican xEducational xResearch xJournal.

Lim, xM. x(2017). xFreedom xto xHate: xSocial xMedia, xAlgorithmic xEnclaves, xand xthe xRise xof xTribal xNationalism xin xIndonesia. xCritical xAsian xStudies, x49(3), x411–427. xhttps://doi.org/10.1080/14672715.2017.1341188

Mongeon, xP., x& xPaul-Hus, xA. x(2016). xThe xJournal xCoverage xof xWeb xof xScience xand xScopus: xA xComparative xAnalysis. xScientometrics, x106(1), x213–228. xhttps://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-015-1765-5

Niyato, xD., xXiao, xL., x& xWang, xP. x(2020). xMachine xlearning xand xbig xdata xanalytics xfor xdigital xtrust. xIEEE xCommunications xSurveys x& xTutorials, x22(2), x854–887.

Paez, xA. x(2017). xGray xliterature: xAn ximportant xresource xin xsystematic xreviews. xJournal xof xEvidence‐Based xMedicine, x10(3), x233–240.

Page, xM. xJ., xMcKenzie, xJ. xE., xBossuyt, xP. xM., xBoutron, xI., xHoffmann, xT. xC., xMulrow, xC. xD., x… xMoher, xD. x(2021). xThe xPRISMA x2020 xStatement: xAn xUpdated xGuideline xfor xReporting xSystematic xReviews. xBMJ, x372, xn71. xhttps://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.n71

Scopus xBibliometric xDataset xon xReligious xModeration, xExtremism, xand xDigital xDiscourse. x(2024). xElsevier xScopus.

Slavin, xR. xE. x(2002). xEvidence-Based xReform xin xEducation. xEducational xResearcher.

van xEck, xN. xJ., x& xWaltman, xL. x(2014). xVisualizing xBibliometric xNetworks. xJournal xof xInformetrics.

Van xEck, xN. xJ., x& xWaltman, xL. x(2010). xSoftware xSurvey: xVOSviewer, xa xComputer xProgram xfor xBibliometric xMapping. xScientometrics, x84(2), x523–538. xhttps://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-009-0146-3

Zaid, xM., x& xHuda, xN. x(2023). xGenerative xAI xand xIslamic xlearning: xChallenges xof xauthority, xtalaqqi, xand xmoderation xin xvirtual xspaces. xJournal xof xContemporary xIslam xand xMuslim xSocieties, x7(2), x145–162.

Zupic, xI., x& xCater, xT. x(2015). xBibliometric xMethods xin xManagement xand xOrganization. Organizational xResearch xMethods, x18(3), x429–472. xhttps://doi.org/10.1177/1094428114562629

Downloads

Published

2026-02-13